Allure+

« What matters most in swimming performance is VO2max. »

It's often said that…

What matters most in swimming performance is VO2max.

In reality…

Comparing swimmers of similar aerobic capacity, the strongest predictor of middle-distance swimming success turned out to be economy — how much oxygen a swimmer uses to hold a given pace — not VO2max itself. Water is roughly 800 times denser than air, and almost all of the energy cost of swimming goes into overcoming drag rather than into forward propulsion, so technique that reduces drag (a longer, cleaner stroke, better body position, less wasted movement) has an outsized effect on performance compared with running or cycling, where the aerobic engine dominates more directly. Two swimmers with the same VO2max can differ enormously in race times purely on economy. This is exactly why swim coaching leans so heavily on stroke technique rather than pure aerobic conditioning: the sport's main limiter is mechanical, not cardiovascular.

Well established

Backed by a meta-analysis or by independent studies that agree.

Sources
Costill D.L., Kovaleski J., Porter D., Kirwan J., Fielding R., King D. (1985). Energy expenditure during front crawl swimming: predicting success in middle-distance events. International Journal of Sports Medicine, 6(5), 266–270. doi:10.1055/s-2008-1025849