Allure+

« Pedaling in perfect circles — actively pulling up on the backstroke — improves cycling efficiency. »

It's often said that…

Pedaling in perfect circles — actively pulling up on the backstroke — improves cycling efficiency.

In reality…

Studies that measured muscle activation and gross efficiency while cyclists deliberately pedaled in rounder circles found the opposite of the intended effect: forcing a more even, 'pulling' pedal stroke increased the activation of muscles working against each other through the pedal cycle and made gross efficiency worse, not better, compared with each cyclist's own natural technique. Left alone, trained cyclists' legs already spend the upstroke relaxing and let momentum and the opposite leg's downstroke carry the pedal through, which turns out to be more efficient than actively pulling. 'Pedaling in circles' produces a smoother-looking pedal stroke and a flatter power trace, but smoother is not the same as more efficient — the two got treated as synonyms for years before anyone actually measured the muscles doing the work.

Well established

Backed by a meta-analysis or by independent studies that agree.

Sources
Korff T., Romer L.M., Mayhew I., Martin J.C. (2007). Effect of Pedaling Technique on Mechanical Effectiveness and Efficiency in Cyclists. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 39(6), 991–995. doi:10.1249/mss.0b013e318043a235