Allure+

« The more cushioning a running shoe has, the better it protects against injury. »

It's often said that…

The more cushioning a running shoe has, the better it protects against injury.

In reality…

Four decades of running-shoe design chased ever more cushioning on the assumption that softer landings mean less impact-related injury, yet injury rates over that period never clearly fell — one of the observations that pushed researchers to question the whole premise. Runners appear to behave the way a driver on studded winter tires does: some evidence points to a 'risk compensation' pattern, where more perceived protection leads to a change in movement (harder landings, altered stride) that partially offsets the shoe's cushioning, an idea formalized as the 'impact moderation' paradox. What actually seems to matter is comfort, not cushioning volume in itself: a runner's body tends to gravitate toward its own natural, well-practiced movement pattern in a shoe that feels right for them, and shoes chosen for that fit are associated with fewer injuries than any specific cushioning specification. A maximally cushioned shoe isn't automatically the safer choice — it's one option among several, and the right one depends on the runner, not a universal amount of foam.

Debated

Openly debated in the literature — sometimes by the very authors of the model.

Sources
Nigg B.M., Baltich J., Hoerzer S., Enders H. (2015). Running shoes and running injuries: mythbusting and a proposal for two new paradigms: 'preferred movement path' and 'comfort filter'. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 49(20), 1290–1294. doi:10.1136/bjsports-2015-095054